Clerk of Court For the Court Gary C. Bertrand And Melissa P. Bertrand v. Glenn J. Patrick; Aig Property Casualty Company; And Louisiana Farm Bureau Casualty Insurance Company C/w Lisa Simpson And Lester Simpson Vs. Glenn Patrick, Aig Property Casualt

The Supreme Court of the State of Louisiana
Clerk of Court
For the Court
GARY C. BERTRAND AND MELISSA P.
BERTRAND
VS.
GLENN J. PATRICK; AIG PROPERTY
CASUALTY COMPANY;
AND LOUISIANA
FARM BUREAU CASUALTY INSURANCE
COMPANY
C/W
LISA SIMPSON AND LESTER SIMPSON
VS.
GLENN PATRICK, AIG PROPERTY
CASUALTY COMPANY AND STATE FARM
MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY
No.2020-CC-00689
_ _ _ _
_ _
IN RE: AIG Property Casualty Company - Applicant Defendant; Glenn Patrick -
Applicant Defendant; State Farm Fire and Casualty Company - Applicant
Defendant; Applying For Supervisory Writ, Parish of Iberville, 18th Judicial District
Court Number(s) 77,752 c/w 77,774, 1st Circuit Court of Appeal, Number(s) 2020
CW 0153;
_ _ _ _ _ _
September 29, 2020
Writ application granted in part. See per curiam.
JDH
BJJ
JLW
SJC
JTG
WJC
JHB
Supreme Court of Louisiana
September 29, 2020
09/29/2020 "See News Release 035 for any Concurrences and/or Dissents."

09/29/20
SUPREME COURT OF LOUISIANA
NO. 2020-CC-0687
NO. 2020-CC-0689
GARY C. BERTRAND AND MELISSA P. BERTRAND
V.
GLENN J. PATRICK, ET AL.
c/w
LISA SIMPSON AND LESTER SIMPSON
V.
GLENN J. PATRICK, ET AL.
ON SUPERVISORY WRITS TO THE EIGHTEEN
JUDICIAL DISTRICT COURT, PARISH OF IBERVILLE
PER CURIAM
Granted in part. Our jurisprudence establishes that “any exception to the
[healthcare provider-patient] privilege should be narrowly tailored and should extend
only to information necessary and relevant to the condition relied on as a defense or
claim.” Moss v. State, 2005-1963 (La. 4/4/06), 925 So.2d 1185, 1201. Accordingly,
it is ordered that defendants produce all responsive documents under seal to the
district court for an in camera review, at which time the district court shall determine
which documents, if any, are subject to production under the exception to the
healthcare provider-patient privilege set forth in La. Code Evid. art. 510(B)(2)(I). In
all other respects, the writ is denied.