Raynetta Jones v. Quality Distribution, Inc., Nsm Insurance Group D/B/A True Transport Insurer and Michael Hammond, Jr.

RAYNETTA JONES * NO. 2021-CA-0280

VERSUS *
COURT OF APPEAL
QUALITY DISTRIBUTION, *
INC., NSM INSURANCE FOURTH CIRCUIT
GROUP D/B/A TRUE *
TRANSPORT INSURER AND STATE OF LOUISIANA
MICHAEL HAMMOND, JR. *******

CONSOLIDATED WITH: CONSOLIDATED WITH:

LATOYA STATUM, RASHAD NO. 2021-CA-0281
HARRIS AND JASON PETERS,
SR. ON BEHALF OF THE MINOR
CHILD, JASON PETERS, JR.

VERSUS

OLD REPUBLIC INSURANCE
COMPANY, QUALITY CARRIER,
INC., AND MICHAEL HAMMOND

APPEAL FROM
CIVIL DISTRICT COURT, ORLEANS PARISH
NO. 2018-06437, DIVISION “A”
Honorable Ellen M Hazeur, Judge
******
Judge Rosemary Ledet
******
(Court composed of Judge Edwin A. Lombard, Judge Roland L. Belsome, Judge
Rosemary Ledet)

Vanessa Motta
MOTTA LAW LLC
3632 Canal Street
New Orleans, LA 70119

COUNSEL FOR PLAINTIFF/APPELLANT

Craig Michael Cousins
Katie F. Wollfarth
Robert L. Bonnaffons
Stanton E. Shuler, Jr.
LEAKE & ANDERSSON, L.L.P.
1100 Poydras Street

1700 Energy Centre
New Orleans, LA 70163-1701

COUNSEL FOR DEFENDANT/APPELLEE

JUDGMENTS VACATED;
REMANDED

AUGUST 4, 2021

RML This is a personal injury suit arising out of a motor vehicle accident. The

EAL plaintiff-appellant, Raynetta Jones, seeks review of the trial court’s February 11,

RLB 2021 judgment, granting the contempt motion filed by the defendants-appellees,

Quality Carrier, Inc.; Michael Hammond; and Old Republic Insurance Co. Ms.

Jones also seeks review of various interlocutory rulings on discovery matters

included in the same judgment (the “First Judgment”).

A review of the record reveals that the trial court signed a second,

conflicting judgment on February 17, 2021 (the “Second Judgment”). The Second

Judgment contains denial stamps on multiple issues set forth in the judgment,

which contradict the trial court’s rulings in the First Judgment and at the hearing.

According to Ms. Jones, “there appear to be two Judgments from the Trial Court

which contradict each other.”

The inclusion in the record of two conflicting judgments renders this court

unable to address the merits of Ms. Jones’ appeal. Although Ms. Jones’ notice of

appeal is from the First Judgment, the record is devoid of any evidence as to the

1

trial court’s intent in signing the Second Judgment. As Ms. Jones points out, “it

remains unknown if the denials on the February 17, 2021 Judgment are the Trial

Court reversing and vacating its prior ruling or simply some sort of mistake made

from the Trial Court.”

Given the procedural posture of this appeal, we find it appropriate to

exercise our discretion under La. C.C.P. art. 21641 to vacate the conflicting

judgments and to remand for the trial court to issue a proper judgment. See La.

C.C.P. art. 2161.2

DECREE

For the foregoing reasons, the February 11, 2021, and February 17, 2021

judgments of the trial court are vacated; and this matter is remanded for the trial

court to issue a proper judgment.

JUDGMENTS VACATED; REMANDED

1
La. C.C.P. art. 2164 provides:

The appellate court shall render any judgment which is just, legal, and
proper upon the record on appeal. The court may award damages, including
attorney fees, for frivolous appeal or application for writs, and may tax the costs
of the lower or appellate court, or any part thereof, against any party to the suit, as
in its judgment may be considered equitable.
2
La. C.C.P. art. 2161 provides:

An appeal shall not be dismissed because the trial record is missing,
incomplete or in error no matter who is responsible, and the court may remand the
case either for retrial or for correction of the record. An appeal shall not be
dismissed because of any other irregularity, error or defect unless it is imputable
to the appellant. Except as provided in Article 2162, a motion to dismiss an appeal
because of any irregularity, error, or defect which is imputable to the appellant
must be filed within three days, exclusive of holidays, of the return day or the date
on which the record on appeal is lodged in the appellate court, whichever is later.

2