Lora Pitre Versus Louisiana Thoroughbred Breeders Association, Warren Harang, III, Jake Delhomme, Daniel Guidry, Val Murrell, David Tillson, and Keith Hernandez

LORA PITRE NO. 21-C-290

VERSUS FIFTH CIRCUIT

LOUISIANA THOROUGHBRED BREEDERS COURT OF APPEAL

ASSOCIATION, WARREN HARANG, III, JAKE STATE OF LOUISIANA

DELHOMME, DANIEL GUIDRY, VAL

MURRELL, DAVID TILLSON, AND KEITH

HERNANDEZ

July 05, 2022

Susan Buchholz
First Deputy Clerk

IN RE LOUISIANA THOROUGHBRED BREEDERS ASSOCIATION, WARREN HARANG, III, JAKE
DELHOMME, DANIEL GUIDRY, VAL MURRELL, DAVID TILLSON, AND KEITH HERNANDEZ, CARROL
CASTILLE, THOMAS EARLY, MICHELLE LAVOICE AND MICHELLE RODRIGUEZ

APPLYING FOR SUPERVISORY WRIT FROM THE TWENTY-FOURTH JUDICIAL DISTRICT COURT,
PARISH OF JEFFERSON, STATE OF LOUISIANA, DIRECTED TO THE HONORABLE DANYELLE M.
TAYLOR, DIVISION "O", NUMBER 814-185

Panel composed of Judges Susan M. Chehardy,
Stephen J. Windhorst, and John J. Molaison, Jr.

WRIT GRANTED; TRIAL COURT'S MAY 3, 2021 ORDER
VACATED; MOTION TO DISMISS DENIED; STAY LIFTED;
REMANDED

Relators/defendants, Louisiana Thoroughbred Breeders Association
(“LTBA”), Warren Harang, III, Jake Delhomme, Daniel Guidry, Val Murrell,
David Tillson, Keith Hernandez, Carrol Castille, Thomas Early, Michelle
Lavoice, and Michele Rodriguez seek review of the trial court’s May 3, 2021
order joining Carrol Castille, Thomas Early, Michelle Lavoice, and Michele
Rodriguez as indispensable parties to respondent/plaintiff, Lora Pitre’s post-
trial motion to strike defendants’ motion for suspensive appeal. In response,
respondent filed a motion to dismiss relators’ writ application as moot. For
the following reasons, we grant this writ application, vacate the trial court’s
May 3, 2021 order joining Carrol Castille, Thomas Early, Michelle Lavoice,
and Michele Rodriguez as indispensable parties to plaintiff’s motion to strike,
lift this court’s June 4, 2021 stay order, and remand for further proceedings.

Trial on plaintiff’s quo warranto petition was held on February 22,
2021. The trial court granted plaintiff’s oral request for a directed verdict,
granted plaintiff’s petition, vacated the current Board Election, and ordered a
new election. The judgment awarded attorney’s fees and costs to plaintiff.
The trial court’s judgment was signed on March 25, 2021, and the judgment
was amended on March 29, 2021 and April 5, 2021.1 In response to relators’
motion for suspensive appeal, plaintiff filed a motion to strike and requested
that the trial court add non-defendant board members of the LTBA, Carrol
Castille, Thomas Early, Michelle Lavoice, and Michele Rodriguez, to the
motion to strike citing La. C.C.P. art. 641. Plaintiff argued that the lawful
members of the LTBA have an interest in this action and the adjudication of
the motion to strike. Plaintiff further argued that in the absence of the non-
defendant board members of the LTBA from the motion to strike, the
individual defendants would continue to usurp authority of the LTBA, divert
and misappropriate the funds of the LTBA and its members and cause
irreparable and irreversible harm to the LTBA. The motion to strike attempted
to preclude the LTBA from filing a motion for suspensive appeal of the
judgment and/or preclude the individual defendants from filing a motion for
suspensive appeal of the judgment based on the erroneous belief that the
LTBA and/or the individual defendant members on behalf of the LTBA could
not file a suspensive appeal from the March 25, 2021 judgment and/or as
subsequently amended.2 Without notice or an opportunity to be heard, the
trial court added Carrol Castille, Thomas Early, Michelle Lavoice, and
Michele Rodriguez as indispensable parties to plaintiff’s post-trial motion to
strike.

Upon review of this writ application, opposition, and exhibits attached
thereto, we find that the trial court erred in impermissibly joining Carrol
Castille, Thomas Early, Michelle Lavoice, and Michele Rodriguez as
indispensable parties, without notice or a contradictory hearing, to plaintiff’s
post-trial motion to strike defendants’ motion for suspensive appeal,
effectively joining them as either party plaintiffs or defendants to the original
petition as amended. La. C.C.P. art. 1951; Oreman v. Oreman, 05-955 (La.
App. 5 Cir. 03/31/06), 926 So.2d 709, 712, writ denied, 06-1130 (La.
09/01/06), 936 So.2d 206. We further find that La. C.C.P. art. 641 allows the
trial court to join parties as indispensable parties to a petition. In this case, the
plaintiff attempted to impermissibly join the non-defendant members of the
board after a trial on the merits to a post-trial motion to strike defendants’
motion for suspensive appeal. Therefore, we vacate the trial court’s May 3,
2021 order joining Carrol Castille, Thomas Early, Michelle Lavoice, and
Michele Rodriguez as indispensable parties.

1 As previously stated in our writ dispositions in 21-CA-195 and 21-CA-247, a review of the March 29, 2021

order and April 5, 2021 orders amending the March 25, 2021 judgment show that these subsequent orders
did not contain the requisite decretal language to be a valid, final judgment. La. C.C.P. art. 1918.
2 We note that as a party to the original action and judgment, the LTBA, as an original named defendant,

and the individually named defendants each have a right to appeal the judgment(s) at issue. The plaintiff
cannot prevent the LTBA, a named defendant, from moving for an appeal of the judgment issued against
it in this case.

Accordingly, we grant this writ application, vacate the trial court’s May 3,
2021 order joining the non-defendant members of the board, Carrol Castille,
Thomas Early, Michelle Lavoice, and Michele Rodriguez, as indispensable parties,
deny plaintiff’s motion to dismiss writ application as moot, lift this court’s
previous June 4, 2021 stay order, and remand this case for further proceedings.

Gretna, Louisiana, this 5th day of July, 2022.

SJW
SMC
JJM

SUSAN M. CHEHARDY CURTIS B. PURSELL

CHIEF JUDGE CLERK OF COURT

MARY E. LEGNON
FREDERICKA H. WICKER
INTERIM CHIEF DEPUTY CLERK
JUDE G. GRAVOIS
MARC E. JOHNSON
ROBERT A. CHAISSON SUSAN S. BUCHHOLZ
STEPHEN J. WINDHORST
FIRST DEPUTY CLERK
HANS J. LILJEBERG
JOHN J. MOLAISON, JR. FIFTH CIRCUIT
MELISSA C. LEDET
JUDGES 101 DERBIGNY STREET (70053)
DIRECTOR OF CENTRAL STAFF
POST OFFICE BOX 489
GRETNA, LOUISIANA 70054 (504) 376-1400

(504) 376-1498 FAX
www.fifthcircuit.org

NOTICE OF DISPOSITION CERTIFICATE OF DELIVERY
I CERTIFY THAT A COPY OF THE DISPOSITION IN THE FOREGOING MATTER HAS BEEN
TRANSMITTED IN ACCORDANCE WITH UNIFORM RULES - COURT OF APPEAL, RULE 4-6 THIS
DAY 07/05/2022 TO THE TRIAL JUDGE, THE TRIAL COURT CLERK OF COURT, AND AT LEAST ONE OF
THE COUNSEL OF RECORD FOR EACH PARTY, AND TO EACH PARTY NOT REPRESENTED BY
COUNSEL, AS LISTED BELOW:

21-C-290
E-NOTIFIED
24th Judicial District Court (Clerk)
Honorable Danyelle M. Taylor (DISTRICT JUDGE)
Beverly A. Delaune (Relator) Judy L. Burnthorn (Relator)
Micah C. Zeno (Respondent) Alexandre E. Bonin (Relator)
R. Christian Bonin (Relator)
Joseph L. McReynolds (Relator)

MAILED
Arthur G. Grimsal (Respondent) John L. Duvieilh (Relator) Jean-Marc Bonin (Relator)
Bryan M. Dupree (Respondent) Attorney at Law Paul A. Bonin (Relator)
Attorney at Law 201 Saint Charles Avenue Attorney at Law
201 Saint Charles Avenue Floor 47 4224 Canal Street
40th Floor New Orleans, LA 70170 New Orleans, LA 70119
New Orleans, LA 70170

• Complete Items 1, 2, and 3.
• Print your name and ac:ldrea8 on the raverse
ao that we can retum the card to you.
• Attach this card to the back of the ~lece.
or on the front If space permits.
1. Mlcle Addre8sed to:
Paul A. Bonin
J ean-Mar.a:Bonin
1 Attomey..s.at Law
4224 C'1i!al Street
New Orleans, LA 70119
2 l-C-290 07-05-22
3. SeMoe Type CJ P1tortty Md~
0 Adult SlgnCre CJ Regill8r9d Md"'
lllllllll llll 111111111111111111111111111111111 ~ReRlctedo.My CJ~Md~
9590 9402 2434 6249 3650 04 a Certllled Md Alllllrtcted D11M1y ~·~tor
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 1 0 Cohcton Dellvely Merdlanclllle
2. Article Number (11ansf!!'.: from service ~ o CoUec:t on Del'-Y FIMt!1oted Oellv8ry a Slgnalln Confhnallon"'
-nsind MIU D SlglllllUnl Conllnnallon
, 7o1 b 2a1 o aaao a9s4 72s7 ~.Jr ReltJfcted DIMy Rl9tllcted Delvely

PS Fonn 3811, July 2015 PSN 7530-02-000-9053

• Complete Items 1, 2, and 3.
• Print your name aid address on the nwerse
so that we can return the card to you.
• Attach this card to the back of the mallplece.
or on the front If space permits.
1. Artlcl9 Addres8ecl to:
Arthur G. Grimsal
Bryt>.n M. Dupree
Attorneys at Law
20 I Saint Charles Avenue/40th Floor
New Orleans, LA 70170
2 l-C-290 07-05-22

II I llllll llll Ill111111111111111111111111111111
9590 9402 2434 6249 3649 91

l PS FOITn 3811, July 2015 PSN 7530-02~

•
• Complete items 1, 2, and 3.

!
Print your name and address on the reverse
so that we can return the card to you.
• Attach this card to the back of the mailpiece,
~on the front if spac_e..;.perm
_ _ its_._ __ _ ___.. t - - - : . . - - - - - " " " " " . . : __ _.___,-'=llLL..:_--
1. Article Addressed to: CJ Yes
ONO
John L. Duvieilh
Attorney at Law
201 Saint Charles Avenue/Floor 47
New Orleans, LA 70170
2 l-C-290 07-05-22
.3. Service Type 0 Priority Mall Expl'llSS9
0 Adult Slgnatunt 0 Regilt-.d Mall"'
111111111111111111111111im 1111111111111111111 0 ~ult Signlllure Reetrlcted Delivery

~
lstered Mail Reetrlcted
IV'Certifled M~ very
9590 9401 ooa3 5168 439? 94 0 Certllled Mall Ree1rtc1ed Delivery
0 Collect on DellYely
eturn Receipt for
Merchandisct
1
i._..,..
2.- Art
- ic
.,.le-.,..,.
Nu _m _ r J!i
_be ..,..r__ans
......,.,.,
- from
-- se-rv_ice
_ /abel)
_ __ _ _-1. D Collect on OelNw)' Restricted Oeliv«y 0 Signature Conflnnation...
0 Insured Mall D Signat1n Confirmation
7Q],b 2070 0000 0954 7233 DlnauredMalR..trictedDeMYory
Restricted Delivery

PS Form 3811, April 2015 PSN 7530-02-000-9053 Domestic Retl.ITI Receipt }